Thanks! Unchecking the "preferred facts" box in the dialog you mentioned did the trick.
FTM uses the term "preferred" inconsistently, as in the Individual & Shared Facts pane within the Person tab, this relates to the use of facts having the same label/identifier.
FTM uses the term "preferred" inconsistently, as in the Individual & Shared Facts pane within the Person tab, this relates to the use of facts having the same label/identifier.